The value of investments and any income from them can fall and you may get back less than you invested.

Should I invest in an equity ISA or a cash ISA?


Making use of your annual £20,000 ISA allowance is one of the bedrocks of sound financial planning.

ISAs can be a highly effective savings tool. They allow your money to grow tax efficiently – you do not have to pay any tax when you make withdrawals or cash them in.

Savers can choose between investing the allowance in cash, stocks and shares, or a mixture of the two. Traditionally, in Britain we have shown ourselves to be a cautious bunch, and roughly 75% of all ISAs are invested wholly in cash.

In 2017/18, the most recent year for which data is available, the proportion of cash ISAs as a percentage of the total fell from 77% to 72%. [1] This was as stock markets were doing very well and had been for some time. But given the recent increase in market volatility, it is likely that next year we will see the proportion of cash ISAs creep back up again as nervous savers get the jitters.

But are most investors right to take the cash option for their savings? The answer is not as simple as you might think.

Short-term cash

Everybody needs cash savings for an emergency fund and cash ISAs are a valuable tool for holding money that you might need to spend in the foreseeable future, whether for emergency expenditure or for regular, planned outgoings such as school fees. If you need to build up this short-term savings fund, then cash ISAs make sense.

Long-term shares

For those looking for more ambitious returns on their money, and who can afford to commit money for years rather than months, stocks and shares ISAs are the standout choice; history has shown that returns on the stock market far outstrip those achieved by cash over the medium to long term. [2]

This is especially true today, as historically low interest rates make most savings accounts uncompetitive. Indeed, research conducted in October showed that only 27 of the more than 1,000 interest-bearing accounts on the market paid rates that were high enough to beat the rate of inflation and maintain the value of your money. [3] In all of the UK’s other interest-bearing accounts, savings would be falling in value because the cost of living is rising more quickly than interest rates are adding to your money.

For example, according to research by Brewin Dolphin, over the past 10 years, the return on cash after taking inflation into account has averaged -1.36% a year, eroding the value of a £10,000 investment by £1,280.

The annualised return on the FTSE All Share index, however, has been 5.1% over 10 years after factoring in inflation, turning a £10,000 investment into £16,454, and equating to a real profit of 64.5% - over and above increases in the cost of living.

Of course, stocks and shares ISAs are not for everybody. You need to be comfortable with the longer timeframe and the fact that your money can fluctuate in value. Stock-market investing can be a bumpy ride and those with savings in the market over recent months may have seen fund portfolios fall by 10% or more, depending on where it has been invested. It can be a gut-churning experience if viewed day to day and there will be people who are not comfortable with what can be a rocky ride.

But for those able to take a long-term perspective, history has shown that share values have outperformed cash over the longer term.



[1]Source:HM Revenue and Customs

[2] Source: E Dimson, PR Marsh and M Staunton, Global Investment Returns Database 2018 (distributed by Morningstar Inc).

[3]Data from Moneyfacts data analysts October 2018

 Article first published: January 2019

Please note that this document was prepared as a general guide only and does not constitute tax or legal advice. While we believe it to be correct at the time of writing, Brewin Dolphin is not a tax adviser and tax law is subject to frequent change. Tax treatment depends on your individual circumstances; therefore you should not rely on this information without seeking professional advice from a qualified tax adviser. Past performance is not a guide to future performance.

No investment is suitable in all cases and if you have any doubts as to an investment's suitability then you should contact us.

We or a connected person may have positions in or options on the securities mentioned herein or may buy, sell or offer to make a purchase or sale of such securities from time to time. In addition we reserve the right to act as principal or agent with regard to the sale or purchase of any security mentioned in this document. For further information, please refer to our conflicts policy which is available on request or can be accessed via our website at

The information contained in this document is believed to be reliable and accurate, but without further investigation cannot be warranted as to accuracy or completeness.

The opinions expressed in this document are not necessarily the views held throughout Brewin Dolphin Ltd.

Newsletter Signup

Stay updated

Receive email updates with news and views from Brewin Dolphin and information on our products and services.

Capturing your post code will allow us to tailor some of our communication to include regional views and updates that may be of interest to you.

We respect your privacy and take protecting it very seriously. We will only use your data in accordance with your preferences stated above. In keeping with our existing practice, we will never sell your personal data to any third parties.

If, in the future, you would like to update any of your marketing communication preferences, you will receive an email that will provide a link to our Preference Centre.

Brewin Dolphin will use the data you provide for the purpose of providing information about events, insights and services we offer.